A Whole Island to Yourself With This Indiana Vacation Rental

Did you know you can rent an island in Indiana? It’s true! A quick two-and-a-half-hour road trip from Indy to Lake Wawasee, just northwest of Fort Wayne.

This article may contain affiliate links. Photos courtesy of VRBO.

Where Can You Rent a Private Island in Indiana?

Beautiful Lake Wawasee is the largest natural lake in the state of Indiana. With this rental, you’ll have a 1.7-acre island to yourself and up to 20 of your closest friends.

The beautiful Wawasee Island has a swimming area that’s out of the way of boat traffic.

There are two buildings on the property for you and your guests to enjoy. The main house has a main bedroom with a king bed, a second bedroom with two queen beds, and a third bedroom with a pair of beds on a loft above two queen beds.

The bunk house has a living room with a pull-out sofa and a bedroom with two sets of bunk beds, each with a twin on top and a full on the bottom. Teens or even a whole family will love having their own space in the bunkhouse.

The main house on the island has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, a large common area, a fully equipped kitchen, and a large screened-in porch.

One of the bedrooms in the main house is perfect for grouping a large family or letting the kids do their own thing.

You’ll have pier space for your watercraft or boats (BYOB – Bring your own boat). Just minutes away by foot, boat, or car, you’ll have access to bars, restaurants, and shopping.

We’re excitedly making a plan for our summer trip with our best friends, Matt & Sam and the plan is full of ideas. We’ll be visiting the nearby perfumery, a few nights out, and maybe some golf for the guys. We want to rent boats and swim and anything else we can find to do with the kids. However, I think I’m most excited for fun evenings on the porch, laughing and playing games with the kids, and then late nights telling stories, listening to music, and drinking cocktails with just the adults.

As for the bunkhouse? We’re auditioning for friends to join us 🙂 Or, maybe we’ll hire a nanny for the week. Send applications our way!
More Info

The reviews for the island are outstanding!

“Great house in an amazing location. I recommend renting a pontoon boat during your stay, it makes exploring the lake so much fun! The location is very dog friendly.” – Richard, Indianapolis

“Lake Wawasee Island House is the place to stay. In the middle of everything, lakes restaurants shopping. I could not have asked for a better place to stay.” –  Lisa, Toledo, Ohio

“Great channel location for lake access and boat watching from the screened patio. Very nice interior amenities and finishes. Our kids loved the lofted beds in the main house. Guest house on the property is great for kids too. Beautiful neighborhood for walks! Cory was a terrific host.” – Cynthia, Carmel, Indiana

“The yard is amazing for dogs! We had such a great time playing cards and eating on the screened in porch.” – Marina, Fishers, Indiana

Book Now!

Here’s a summary of things you can do at Lake Wawasee:

  1. Boating and Water Sports: Lake Wawasee is ideal for boating, with options to rent pontoon boats. It’s also great for swimming, fishing, motor boating, and water skiing, making it a perfect destination for water enthusiasts.
  2. Golfing: The area around Lake Wawasee offers golfing opportunities for those who want to spend some time on the greens.
  3. Exploring Local Eateries and Shopping: The community around Lake Wawasee is home to unique eateries and shops, providing a delightful local experience. You can find fresh seafood at quaint restaurants or enjoy an evening around a fire pit at the Sleepy Owl Supper Club.
  4. Taking a Cruise: The SS Lillypad offers a two-story, 110-passenger dinner boat experience on Lake Wawasee, allowing you to enjoy the lake’s beauty from the water.
  5. Visiting Local Parks and Festivals: Lakeside Park offers a relaxing picnic spot, and the area is known for its engaging festivals that visitors can enjoy.
  6. Souvenir Hunting: For those interested in shopping, the Artisan and Farmers Market is a great place to find souvenirs and local crafts.

The surrounding areas of Kosciusko County, where Lake Wawasee is located, also offer various attractions and activities. From the cultural and artistic experiences in Warsaw to the lakeside relaxation in Winona Lake, there’s something for everyone. North Webster is noted for its outdoor activities, especially on the water, including rides on the Dixie sternwheeler. Meanwhile, Pierceton is known for its antiques and collectibles, providing a unique shopping experience​

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top